は別(べつ)として (wa betsu toshite)
~は別として — “aside from ~ / setting ~ aside”
Pattern
-
名詞+は別としてsetting aside ~ (also 〜は別にして) -
動詞辞書形/名詞(疑問詞+か)+かは別としてwhether ~ or not aside, …
Treating it as a separate issue
A は別として、B means “whatever A is, B is what matters or what I will say.” It does not deny A; it just sets it aside for now. 値段は別として、デザインは気に入った: price is another question, but I like the design.
Common uses
A fixed phrase 冗談は別として (joking aside) is used to return to the main subject. 結果は別として shows that the process matters more than the result. A can also be a clause: 本当かどうかは別として.
Close expressions
~はさておき is very similar and a little more written. ~はともかく also sets A aside, but with the sense that A is less important. ~は別として is the most neutral.
Examples
-
値段(ねだん)は別(べつ)として、デザインは気(き)に入(い)った。
Nedan wa betsu toshite, dezain wa ki ni itta.
Aside from the price, I like the design.
-
冗談(じょうだん)は別(べつ)として、そろそろ本題(ほんだい)に入(はい)ろう。
Joudan wa betsu toshite, sorosoro hondai ni hairou.
Joking aside, let’s get to the main topic now.
-
結果(けっか)は別(べつ)として、最後(さいご)まで頑張(がんば)ったことが大事(だいじ)だ。
Kekka wa betsu toshite, saigo made ganbatta koto ga daiji da.
Aside from the result, what matters is that you tried until the end.
Common mistakes
- It does not mean “A is unimportant”. It only sets A aside for now. For “A matters less”, ~はともかく fits better.
- A must be a noun or a noun-like phrase (verbs need こと or か: 行くかどうかは別として).