は〜が〜は (wa~ga... wa)
~は~が、~は~ — contrasting two things
Pattern
-
A は ~(です/ます)が、B は ~A は ~が、B は ~ (contrast; the が means “but”)
Two roles of は
は marks contrast as well as the topic. 夏は好きです says “summer, at least, I like”, and by itself it already hints that something else may not be liked. When two は-phrases are placed together, the contrast becomes clear.
The が in the middle
The が between the clauses is the conjunction “but”, not the subject marker. The two clauses are often positive and negative, or the same verb with different amounts: よく話しますが、あまり話しません.
Examples
-
夏(なつ)は好(す)きですが、冬(ふゆ)は好(す)きじゃありません。
Natsu wa suki desu ga, fuyu wa suki ja arimasen.
I like summer, but I don't like winter.
-
肉(にく)は食(た)べますが、魚(さかな)は食(た)べません。
Niku wa tabemasu ga, sakana wa tabemasen.
I eat meat, but I don't eat fish.
-
姉(あね)はよく話(はな)しますが、弟(おとうと)はあまり話(はな)しません。
Ane wa yoku hanashimasu ga, otōto wa amari hanashimasen.
My older sister talks a lot, but my younger brother doesn't talk much.
Common mistakes
- Do not use が after the object in place of は: 肉が食べますが is wrong; keep を or は as a contrast (肉は).
- The middle が means “but”. Do not read it as a subject marker.